« Adopting an American accent: It's like wearing a suit | Main | Which accent is best? »
Thursday
Aug202009

I don't like "accent reduction"!

 

I don't like the term "accent reduction"... or even "accent modification". Why??? Because these terms imply that your accent is a bad thing. As I said in my previous post, I think all accents are equally valid. It's just that one accent may be more useful than another in a certain location, or when interacting with certain people.

The term "accent reduction" begins with the premise that you are trying to get rid of something bad, or fix something that is broken. But you are not broken! To suggest that your speech is broken or bad is to approach your speech training from a negative mindset. And, of course, a negative mindset will only be a hindrance to your success.

So, to approach your accent training from with a positive perspective, I much prefer terms like "accent adoption" or "accent acquisition". You are not trying to get rid of a "bad" thing... instead, you are trying to learn another good thing!

Many of my clients have confided with me that they were nervous about learning to speak with an American accent because they were afraid that they might lose their own non-native accent. For example, a businessman from Japan who spoke English with a strong Japanese accent wanted to "reduce" his accent so the Americans he works with would understand him better. But if he were to "reduce" his native accent, he was afraid that he would stand out as being different when speaking English in the presence of his Japanese colleagues; he feared they would think that he would be "showing off" by speaking English in a way that is much "better" (or "different") than everyone else.

This kind of situation can create a lot of psychological conflict. Our cultural values are powerful motivators (or de-motivators). In this case, the value of group harmony and the desire to not stand out as being different from the group will likely be stronger than a person's desire to make changes to his speaking patterns. This conflict can create a huge psychological barrier to accent acquisition, and you can be predisposed to failure even before getting started!

People are usually not consciously aware of this psychological conflict, so the first step is to acknowledge it. Once you recognize this within yourself, you can then consciously decide that you are not going to let it hold you back from success... it's a choice that you can make!

What are your thoughts on this? Do you have any psychological blocks like this??? Please post a comment with your thoughts.

And stay tuned... I'll share with you a new way of thinking about accent adoption in a future post.

 

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (5)

I would say that the purpose of any forms of the communication is to be understandable. The easier to be understood the more effective. Our speech is not exceptional. I know people with accent and they are easy to understand. I also know people with similar accent they are hard to follow. If we have the attitude and desire to be the best communicator, it wouldn't be matter what terms are used to make it happen, either "accent reduction", "accent modification" etc.

2009.08.24 | Unregistered CommenterLaura

Hi Accent Guy! I like your site! I provide communication skills training & I am all about making people crystal clear and persuasive. I agree with you and laura--it's not about reducing anything, it's about being a highly effective communicator in all environments. I'll be following you on twitter as olsenspeech. please follow me too!
best,
ita

2009.08.26 | Unregistered Commenterita olsen

Thanks for your comment, Ita... glad to have you join the conversation! You and Laura are both right... it's ultimately about becoming more effective communicators. No matter how we may label the process, that's what we're all striving for, right?!?

2009.08.28 | Registered CommenterKevin

Probably the biggest problem with accent reduction is that, at first, it’s not natural. You’re going against the grain as far as the way you normally speak. Now, you might not think that this is a problem, but just wait until you’re half way through your course and you’re also half way between speaking like you usually do and speaking like you want to speak. It’s kind of like when a young boy goes through puberty. It’s not a fun thing to listen to. You’ll feel self conscious about the way you speak for quite some time until you finally get the hang of it.

@nahrungsergänzung Thanks for your comment. Yes, the awkwardness and discomfort of how a boy's voice changes as he goes through puberty is a great illustration of how many people feel when adopting a new accent!

When my clients comment to me about how strange they feel when they speak in a new way, I assure them that it's completely normal to feel that way… and, early on until the ears have become accustomed to hearing their own voice with a new accent, that weird feeling can be a good indicator of successful accent adoption. --> "If it feels/sounds really funny to you, that probably means you're doing it right!" : )

See also my post entitled Does Your New Accent Make You a Fake?

2009.12.16 | Registered CommenterKevin

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>